Experiment Two
Two weeks after the first one, another experiment. And my first thought is: isn’t this a bit
dangerous? Hot water in cans that buckle and cave in? The teacher’s really got to be 100%
sure his grasp of Physics is up to par, or we could be looking at a class full of maimed kids.
Not that anyone would have really cared about that back then. But I’d have a hard time
believing you could do this experiment with a bunch of eight year olds in 2021.
Again, I’m not sure I’ve written this up in the most effective manner. Yes, I’ve described what
happened, but I don’t think I quite grasped why. I mean, if the top’s on, the steam can’t
escape, so surely the pressure of the steam - which wants to escape the bottle - must make
it explode outwards, not buckle and implode?
Got to find a way of explaining it.
Maybe using another experiment on the internet will help.
OK, here’s one: https://coolscienceexperimentshq.com/how-to-crush-a-bottle/ -
This one uses a plastic bottle and, crucially, needs to be lying in a bed of ice, with cold water
poured onto it. I expect we managed to skip this part because we were in Yorkshire in the
middle of November (so it was already icy enough), but it’s entirely possible I just forgot to
mention it.
The way it works, apparently, is that cool air exerts less pressure than warm air. The air in
the bottle is room temperature until hot water is added, which heats the air. But when the
air cools, the pressure decreases, and if there’s nowhere for the hot air to go, the pressure of
the air outside the bottle is greater than the pressure of the air inside, and the bottle caves
in. For some reason… No, I still don’t understand it…
Can you explain it to me? Please write to waen@waenshepherd.com and tell me how
it works. I’ll write up the best answers here so everyone can see them. So definitely
don’t write me silly answers.
Air Pressure
FAIRBURN
The place where I wrote
all this rubbish
WAEN SHEPHERD
Who was this strange
little boy?
GEOGRAPHY 1
Sept 1979 - Feb 1981
HISTORY 1
Sept 1979 - Oct 1981
The Forgotten World
John and Mick fall foul
of some extreme
potholing
Christmas 1979
Can Waen last the night
without opening his
presents?
Great Space Battles
Three mighty empires
take their first steps
into outer space
TERM 1
A day-by-day account of
Waen’s first term at
Fairburn School
TERM 2
The birth of the 1980s -
Blake’s 7, Blondie and
battles in space
TOPIC 1
He knows the names of
all the dinosaurs
TOPIC 2
The one where it all
kicks off
Waen Shepherd 2
Waen’s heroic antics in
the far-flung future of
2007 AD!
Experiment Two
Two weeks after the first one, another experiment.
And my first thought is: isn’t this a bit dangerous?
Hot water in cans that buckle and cave in? The
teacher’s really got to be 100% sure his grasp of
Physics is up to par, or we could be looking at a
class full of maimed kids. Not that anyone would
have really cared about that back then. But I’d have
a hard time believing you could do this experiment
with a bunch of eight year olds in 2021.
Again, I’m not sure I’ve written this up in the most
effective manner. Yes, I’ve described what
happened, but I don’t think I quite grasped why. I
mean, if the top’s on, the steam can’t escape, so
surely the pressure of the steam - which wants to
escape the bottle - must make it explode outwards,
not buckle and implode?
Got to find a way of explaining it.
Maybe using another experiment on the internet
will help.
OK, here’s one:
https://coolscienceexperimentshq.com/how-to-
crush-a-bottle/ -
This one uses a plastic bottle and, crucially, needs to
be lying in a bed of ice, with cold water poured onto
it. I expect we managed to skip this part because we
were in Yorkshire in the middle of November (so it
was already icy enough), but it’s entirely possible I
just forgot to mention it.
The way it works, apparently, is that cool air exerts
less pressure than warm air. The air in the bottle is
room temperature until hot water is added, which
heats the air. But when the air cools, the pressure
decreases, and if there’s nowhere for the hot air to
go, the pressure of the air outside the bottle is
greater than the pressure of the air inside, and the
bottle caves in. For some reason… No, I still don’t
understand it…
Can you explain it to me? Please write to
waen@waenshepherd.com and tell me how it
works. I’ll write up the best answers here so
everyone can see them. So definitely don’t write
me silly answers.
WAEN SHEPHERD
Who was this strange
little boy?
GEOGRAPHY 1
Sept 1979 - Feb 1981
Darth Vader
An autograph from a
genuine stand-in
The Forgotten World
John and Mick fall foul
of some extreme
potholing
String Orchestra
A visit from the North
Yorkshire County
Council Orchestra
Bonfire Night
Waen’s first time at the
annual village fireworks
display
Air Pressure
TERM 1
A day-by-day account of
Waen’s first term at
Fairburn School
TOPIC 2
The one where it all
kicks off
Waen Shepherd 2
Waen’s heroic antics in
the far-flung future of
2007 AD!
Ward’s 7
John Ward and his band
of rebels fight the evil
Federation